SMS two-factor authentication is weaker than most people assume — and most banks still use it
Most people know that reusing passwords is bad and that some kind of second factor helps. SMS two-factor authentication is what most of us ended up with, because it shipped as the default everywhere and doesn't require an app. When you log into a bank or a retail account and they text you a 6-digit code, that's it.
The problem is that SMS isn't a secure channel. The main attack is SIM swapping: a fraudster calls your carrier's customer service, provides enough information to pass their verification — much of which is scraped from data breaches or social media — and convinces the rep to transfer your number to a SIM card they control. When that succeeds, your phone stops getting calls or texts, and the attacker's does. Including 2FA codes.
This isn't theoretical. The FBI started issuing SIM swap warnings in 2022 after losses crossed $70 million in a year. High-profile targets — crypto holders, journalists, executives — have been hit repeatedly. The technique doesn't require any technical sophistication. It requires social engineering a customer service agent.
The SS7 protocol is a second problem. The signaling layer phone networks use to route calls and texts was designed in 1975, before anyone thought about adversarial use. If you have access to SS7 infrastructure — which intelligence agencies do, and which can be rented from certain gray-market telecom operators — you can intercept SMS messages without touching the carrier at all.
TOTP apps (Google Authenticator, Authy, Aegis) generate codes locally without a carrier in the loop. Hardware keys (YubiKey, passkeys tied to a device) are better still. Neither can be bypassed by calling T-Mobile.
The reason SMS persists is real: no app to download, works on every phone, customers don't bounce. The business case for switching to TOTP is "users are more secure" and the business case against is "some users won't set it up and we lose the account." The second argument has historically won.
Has anyone here actually gone through the exercise of moving all their financial accounts to TOTP or hardware keys? And did any institution refuse to let you do it?
0 replies