VPNs are marketed as privacy tools, but most people don't…

VPNs are marketed as privacy tools, but most people don't understand what they actually protect against

VPNs are marketed as privacy tools, but most people don't understand what they actually protect against

Every few months there's a news story about an ISP selling browsing data or a government surveillance program, and VPN subscriptions spike. The pitch is consistent: install this, and your internet activity is private. The reality is more specific than that.

A VPN moves trust from one place to another. Without it, your ISP can see every domain you request and roughly when. With it, your ISP sees only an encrypted tunnel to a VPN server, which is a genuine improvement in that specific scenario. But the site you end up at still sees your traffic. The VPN provider now sees everything your ISP used to see. And all the other ways you can be tracked — first-party cookies, login sessions, browser fingerprinting, the fact that you're logged into an account — are completely unaffected.

The worst case is a VPN that's actively hostile. Some free VPN providers have sold user data or injected ads. The incentive structure for a "free" service that sits in the middle of all your traffic is worth thinking about before installing.

What a VPN actually helps with: your ISP can't see your DNS queries and traffic, you're less exposed on a hostile network like a coffee shop wifi, and you can appear to be in a different country for geo-restricted content. These are real, narrow use cases.

What it doesn't help with: your browser history when you're logged in, tracking cookies that follow you across sites, your real identity in anything requiring a login, or an adversary who controls the site you're visiting.

The mismatch between the marketing and the actual threat model is large enough that people make security decisions based on it. Thinking "I have a VPN" and then logging into everything normally is roughly equivalent to wearing a raincoat while swimming — you have protection in one direction.

What actually helps depends on what you're worried about. Has anyone gone through the exercise of actually mapping their own threat model — and found that a VPN was or wasn't the right answer for it?

0 replies